Sustainability Store

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Aquaponics

Part 1 - What is Aquaponics and How is it Better than Soil Gardening and Hydroponics?

Aquaponics is the union of Hydroponics (growing plants without soil) and Aquaculture (raising fish). The concept dates back thousands of years to ancient Egypt and the Aztecs, who built floating islands for growing crops in canals where they raised fish. Ancient far East cultures, like China and Thailand, raised Koi in their rice paddies. The Creole peoples in the Southern United States introduced Crawfish to their rice paddies because it offered an additional food source for the farmer - a practice that was later picked up in China. What do all of these farming practices have in common? They all use raw marine waste as the sole nutrient source for the plants. When the conditions are right, bacterial cultures convert the raw ammonia waste into Nitrites (Nitrosoma sp. bacteria) then into Nitrates (Nitrospira sp. and Nitrobacter sp. bacteria) which are readily available for plants to use. These same bacteria are responsible for the Nitrogen Cycle in soil, but it is much easier to create the ideal conditions (pH, temperature, available oxygen) for the bacteria in water. While it is possible to measure soil temperature and pH the process is time consuming and you can never be sure that the sample collected for testing represents the whole grow bed. Poorly distributed buffers like limestone can easily create pH hot spots and the shade from the growing plants can fluctuate the soil/root temperatures. Furthermore, oxygen concentration in soil is exceedingly difficult to control. One accidental over-watering can deplete the soil of oxygen, kill off the active bacteria cultures, and drown the plant (plants require oxygen at the roots to exchange nutrients). In aquaponics and hydroponics, the water is heavily aerated (introducing dissolved oxygen) and circulated to ensure a uniform pH and temperature, which can be monitored continuously by digital meters; pH can also be verified using simple aquarium test kits.

In a soil-less grow, nutrients are available as the plants need them. In soil, time-release fertilizers are used to ensure that nutrients are available until the next application. However, these time-release fertilizers often run off during the next rain and are a huge contributor to polluted water supplies. Fertilizers intended for hydroponics should not be used in soil because they will drain off before they even have a chance to be metabolized by the Nitrifying bacteria in the soil. Plants will stress during the "feast or famine" presented by nutrient overdose, followed by zero nutrients until the next watering.

So, by now you may see the benefit of soil-less over soil gardening, but you may be asking "why not hydroponics?" The simple answer... hydroponics nutrients are bottled in a salt form to ensure shelf-life rather than their whole, organic, form. In the absence of oxygen (e.g. a bottle of fertilizer on a shelf), Denitrifying bacteria such as pseudomonas sp., alkaligenes sp., and bacillus sp., would break down whole organic matter and release Nitrogen gas - causing the fertilizer to ferment. To avoid this, fertilizer companies ship only salt-based fertilizers or organic fertilizers with an antimicrobial agent (which also hinders the Nitrifying bacteria in your system when you need it most). Salt-based fertilizers must first be broken down from their salt form before they can be used. Then, these salts accumulate in your system which limits the plants ability to uptake water and nutrients. To combat this, hydroponics growers frequently replace their water - resulting in a costly loss of nutrients, wasted water, and environmental pollution. With this frequent water change, a hearty bacteria culture does not have time to establish. Aquaponics suffers from none of these setbacks, because nutrients are continuously produced fresh and ready for the plants to use. The key is the bacteria culture. Like a fine wine, an aquaponics system needs to age to become established. As the system ages, the bacteria culture grows and becomes more robust. As the bacteria culture grows it is able to process more waste and produce more nutrients... meaning it can support more plants or plants with higher nutrient demands. A well-establish aquaponics system can produce roughly 30% higher yield and 30% faster growth rate than a hydropinics system (which is already 50% faster than soil-based growing).

Food for Thought: The most common fertilizers are potassium nitrate and ammonium nitrate. Both are harmful if swallowed/inhaled/ingested and if they come in contact with skin they should be thoroughly washed away. Both are most commonly made from chemically processed salts extracted from mined minerals. Both are used in making explosives. Both have extensive handling and disposal instructions. Fish poop... well, that's already in the rivers, and as gross as it may sound, is perfectly safe to drink. Which would you rather have traces of in your crops?

Stay Tuned for More Updates! Like. Share. Comment. Post. Whatever you feel is right. More to come soon. Please vote on the poll to the right if this is the section you would like to see expanded next, thanks!

3 comments:

  1. Hi, Firstly tahnks for a great site.
    I have a question in regards to blue barrels. I have a few barrells that have had sorbitol and lanolin cream in them, is it safe to use these for aquaponics as I am not sure of the leachability or the safety of the prior contents.
    Thanks Mick

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mick,

      Thanks for your comment. My apologies for not getting back to you sooner. I have been away from my computer and my phone would not let me post a reply. I have been looking into these two compounds for you. Sorbitol is water soluble (so it should easily wash out), organic (since it is typically derived from corn syrup), and most importantly... it is commonly found in fish food. I am confident that this will not harm your aquaponics system. Anything left in the barrels will be broken down by the bacteria cultures. Just to be safe, however, I would still wash it out as thoroughly as you can. However, I am not as confident about the lanolin cream. While it is an organic compound (made from oil extracted from sheep wool), it is oil based and may be difficult to clean out. I don't see any reason it should harm the fish or plants in residual form, but large quantities of oil in the water would interfere with the fish gills and the root uptake of nutrients if the oil present is thick enough to form a coating on a surface. For a rain barrel, this could be prohibitively difficult, but for your aquaponics system you should be able to easily clean out the residue once the barrels are cut open. After you have cleaned the barrels, add some water and let it sit for a little while. If there is still residue present you will be able to see colorful swirls on the surface of the water. I hope you find this information helpful and wish you the best of luck in setting up your aquaponics system.

      Regards,
      Jake

      Delete
  2. The science of soil-less gardening is called hydroponics. It basically involves growing healthy plants without the use of a traditional greencoast hydroponics soil medium by using a nutrient like a mineral rich water solution instead. A plant just needs select nutrients, some water, and sunlight to grow.

    ReplyDelete